 |
|
|
 |
| |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Which
insulin to use? Human or animal? by V.Mohan., Current Science.,
Vol 83, No.12, 25 Dec. 2002 |
 |
| Animal
Insulin : Revisited by Dr. Anil S. Bhoraskar, API Medicine
update, Vol 12, Chapter 44, 2002 |
 |
| Cochrane
review -Endocrinology and metabolism clinics of North America
- Sep 2002 |
 |
| Youth-onset
Diabetes in India by N. Kochupillai and R. Goswami, RSSDI
Textbook of Diabetes, April 2002. |
 |
|
Insulin Antibody Response to Bovine Insulin Therapy by N.
Kochupillai , API Medicine update, 2002. |
|
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
| |
| |
| |
|
 |
| |
| Youth-onset Diabetes in India: Nature of
Diabetes and Use of Bovine Insulin in their Treatement |
| N. Kochupillai, R. Goswami |
| |
| RSSDI Textbook of Diabetes, April
2002. |
Around 10% of diabetics
in India have onset below 30 years of age. Youth-onset diabetes
in developing countries is a heterogenous set of disorders.
Till recently, information on occurrence, chnico-pathological
and biochemical features as well as etiology of youth onset
diabetes in India were not coherent. Though in 1985, a WHO
group of experts classified youth-onset diabetes in developing
countries into different categories, that classification has
recently been questioned and is now under review. Meanwhile
type1 diabetes as seen in the West being more clearly defined
immunologically and sub-categories are emerging on the basis
of natural history and immune markers. |
| |
At the AlIMS we operate a "diabetes
in the young" clinic. Patients with age of onset of
diabetes <30 years are registered in this clinic and
provided state of the art diabetic care free of cost. The
clinic has registry of 1033 with an average of 110 fresh
patients registered each year. Catchment area of the clinic
spreads beyond confinement of Delhi and includes States
like Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Haryana, Bihar, Jammu and
Kashmir, West Bengal, Assam and Orissa. A recent analysis
of the patients attending clinic showed that 60%, of them
were socioeconomically poor with monthly income of parents
up to Rs.2,000. In our clinic it is common to have patients
with type1 diabetes mellitus presenting with ketoacidosis
as a result of interrupted insulin therapy due to financial
constraints. Young patients with ketosis-resistant diabetes
present in states of extreme wasting due to chronically
poor glycemic control.
|
| |
| A. Subtypes of youth-onset diabetes in Northern
India |
The study subjects comprised
of 132 consecutive patients with diagnosis of diabetes less
than 30 years of age who attended the "Diabetes in the
Young" Clinic on the AIIMS during the 2 year period spanning
1995-1997. The mean age was 25±8.0 and mean duration
5.5±6.0 years. 49 patients were females while 83 were
males. |
| |
Clinical characteristics,
insulin requirement, ketosis proneness on insulin withdrawal,
fami1v history of diabetes, nutritional status and radiological
and ultrasonographical evidences of pancreatic calculi were
assessed. C-peptide was measured at 0 and 6 mts. post glucagons
(1 mg IN). The daily insulin dose requirements were assessed
by close monitoring of blood glucose with administration of
purified insulin before the three principal meals to achieve
ideal glycemic status throughout the day (fasting blood glucose
< 120 mg% and post meal < 140 mg%). The patients were
categorized as type 1, type 2 and fibrocalculous pancreatopathy
(FCPD). Type1 diabetes was diagnosed if ketosis developed
on insulin withdrawal. Fibrocalculous pancreatopathy was diagnosed
on the basis of pancreatic calculi on plain X-ray abdomen
or ultrasonography. Diagnosis of type 2 diabetes was made
if subjects achieved glycemic control without insulin and
with normal or above normal body mass indices (BMI). Diabetes
as part of an autoimmune polyglandular syndrome was considered
if there was a co-existing clinically overt autoimmune thyroid
disorder. No other organ specific autoimmune disorder coexisted
with the present group of youth-onset diabetic individuals.
Additionally, an entity designated as 'ketosis resistant type'
was categorised. These were insulin requiring youth-onset
diabetic individuals, who were resistant to ketosis on insulin
withdrawal and who has low BMI with other features of malnutrition.
More recently, an International Workshop (1995) named this
entity 'malnutrition modulated diabetes (MMDM)'. They did
not have seen in type1 and autoimmune polyglandular groups
respectively. The fibrocalculous pancreatopathy group showed
GAD 65 plus IA-2 autoantibody positivity in 14.2% and lone
GAD 65 autoantibody positivity in 7.1%. Twenty six percent
and 60% respectively of the type 1 and autoimmune polyalandular
syndrome groups had thyroid nucrosomal autoantibody positivity.
Type 1 showed significantly less C-peptide response to glucagons
when compared to the ketosis-resistant and autoinimune polyglandular
syndrome groups. The controls and type 2 diabetic individuals
tested negative for tested cell autoimmunity markers. |
| |
| Thus the largest group among youth-onset diabetes
in North India can be categorized as type1 diabetes |
| |
| The ketosis-resistant group
was the second most prevalent type. The unique features of
the entity brought forward by the present study include:
- High frequency of GAD 65 positivity (38%).
- Relatively low frequency of combined GAD 65 and IA-2
autoantibody positivity.
- Better basal and glucagons stimulated C-peptide response
when compared to type1 diabetic individuals.
The fibrocalcalculous pancreatopathy related
diabetes is another well-recognized group of youth-onset diabetic
individuals. Three of 14 such patients had either GAD 65 and/or
IA-2A positivity with an overall, islet cell autoimmunity
marker positivity of 21.3%. These observations suggest that
diabetes causation in this syndrome may also involve autoimmune
islet cell damage presumably triggered by islet cell destruction
in pancreatitis. Overall the results of the present study,
thus, indicate a dominant role of islet cell autoirnmunity
in the pathogenesis of most types of youth onset diabetes
in Northern India. |
| |
B. Insulin antibody response
to bovine insulin therapy and its functional significance
among insulin requiring young diabetics in India |
Seventy patients (43 males and 27 females, mean (SD) age
17.9±6.1 years, mean duration of Bovine insulin therapy
5.1 ± 5.4 years, were studied.
Radiobinding assays for specific insulin binding was carried
out by using a 121 tracer of human insulin prepared in our
laboratory using Chloramine-T technique. The mean and specific
binding of 100 healthy subjects without any family-history
of diabetes or other autoimmune disease was 0.9±1.1%.
The insulin antibody titres observed in patients was expressed
in the assay precision unit, SD score.
Briefly, all the patients treated with bovine insulin showed
high titres of insulin antibodies with SD score ranging
from 5.1 to 42. No significant difference was observed in
the mean SD score of insulin antibodies in the three diabetic
groups. Insulin antibodies SD score and its affinity did
not show significant relationship with daily insulin dose
and HBAI at admission. Only 27±7% variations in daily
insulin dose requirement were accounted for by total insulin
binding power. There was a significant inverse relationship
between insulin antibody SD score and duration of insulin
therapy (r = -0, 4172, p<0.0004).
There was no relationship between insulin antibody titres
and daily insulin dose requirement. In fact despite presence
of high insulin antibody titres, daily insulin dose requirement
remained within physiological range in all three types of
diabetics studied. The major variation in insulin dose requirement
is thus governed by factors other than insulin antibody.
Overall, these results indicate that bovine insulin related
antibody response does not result in any clinically significant
impact in terms of daily insulin requirement for diabetes
control.
|
| |
| References |
- Tripathy BB, Samal KC.Overview and consensus
statement on diabetes in tropical areas. Diabetes Metabol
Rev 1997; 13: 63-76
-
Goswami R, Jaleel A, Kochupillai N
Insulin Antibody response to bovine insulin therapy insulin
therapy: functional significance among insulin requiring
young diabetics in India. Diabetes Research and Clinical
Practice 2000; 49: 7-15.
|
|